Pubs, hotels, farmers and tourism operators across regional Australia are breathing a sigh of relief after the federal government watered down a proposal to slash the number of backpackers allowed to stay and work in the country for a third year.
Working holiday-makers who want to stay in Australia for a third year were going to be forced into a ballot for a shot at one of just 5,000 visas, down from the roughly 31,000 third-year visas currently granted each year. But Labor has now walked that limit back, lifting the third-year backpacker cap to 25,000, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke announced on Tuesday.
The backtrack is the latest twist in a migration crackdown first unveiled in September, when Mr Burke announced a suite of changes designed to pull migration-driven population growth down from about 300,000 people a year to a long-term target of 225,000. The backpacker ballot was one of the most contested parts of that package, drawing fierce warnings from the tourism, hospitality and farming sectors that it would strip regional Australia of both seasonal workers and free-spending young visitors.
Under the revised arrangements, backpackers seeking a third year of working in Australia can now bid for one of 25,000 visas. Second-year backpacker visas will also remain capped at 45,000 places, but visitors will need to work in the regions for 120 days — rather than the current 88 days — to qualify from March onwards. They will still need to meet the existing requirement of six months of regional work to stay for a third year.
The Australian Hotels Association welcomed the change. Its chief executive, Stephen Ferguson, said the higher cap was a much better outcome for regional and remote Australia than when the new migration measures were first announced, calling the backtrack common sense.
“To be blunt, we would have preferred to keep the old demand-driven system, but the government has listened to our concerns,” Mr Ferguson said. “Now we just need to get on with it.”
The higher caps on backpackers would not stop the government hitting its closely watched migration targets, the immigration minister said. “That’s what’s forecast in the budget, that’s what we’re doing, that needs to happen,” Mr Burke said. “The total numbers haven’t changed — we work with industry in making sure that we get the best possible landing for the economy.”
The opposition was unconvinced. The coalition and One Nation had heaped pressure on the government to stem a post-pandemic arrivals surge, both promising deeper cuts, but Opposition Leader Angus Taylor said the ballots were a clumsy way of lowering migration.
“Working-holiday visas are an important part of our migration mix and we want to see more of it in regional areas … but they’ve created a complete mess with this raffle,” he said. “He’s lost control of our borders and, at the same time, he’s failed to deliver the skills we need.”
Nationals leader Matt Canavan said there was no need for backpacker caps at all, touting the coalition’s pledge to concentrate migration cuts on student, graduate and bridging visas instead.
“This government refuses to take serious action … so it was left with a half-hearted action on backpacker visas, which has been a complete disaster,” he said. “It does concern me that we keep tinkering here with a program that works.”
Senator Canavan said it was unnecessary to meddle with the arrangements around British working holiday-makers, which fall under a free trade agreement, suggesting the government could increase visa fees if it wanted fewer of them.
British backpackers are exempt from the rural work requirement under the Australia–UK free trade agreement, and a slowdown order on visas for British backpackers was giving the migration system “headspace” to ensure the totals stacked up, Mr Burke added. Labor wants the exemption removed entirely to help slow arrivals of UK working holiday-makers, but that did not fly with British Prime Minister Andy Burnham when he met with Prime Minister Anthony Albanese earlier in November.
The farming sector gave the announcement a cautious welcome. The National Farmers Federation said Mr Burke’s announcement was a step in the right direction, but “logistical realities” needed to be ironed out before it could fully support it. Backpackers filled roughly one in seven farm jobs, the federation said.
Tourism and Transport Forum chief executive Margy Osmond agreed the changes needed to go further. “The caps need to go,” she said. The sector had previously warned Labor’s changes would damage Australia’s reputation as a sought-after destination and harm tourism-dependent areas.
