In an opinion piece for Quadrant, published on the first day of early voting in Victoria’s state election, the author argues that the contest’s likely winner has already shown voters why they should doubt her — and that principle, not polling, is what is missing from the campaign.
The author stood in line to vote on Wednesday, the first day of early voting, expecting to feel hope at the prospect of ending Labor’s reign. For all but four of the past twenty-seven years, Labor governments have presided over Victoria, the piece notes — the better ones merely incompetent, the worst corrupt beyond the former limits of imagination. Yet where hope should be burgeoning, the author confesses, there is an unease that verges on despair. Last night’s News24 debate is part of the reason.
The studio audience rated Liberal leader Jess Wilson the runaway winner of the four-corner bout, the author writes, a conclusion the polls have long since affirmed in anointing her Liberals the near certain victor on November 28. The debate, hosted by News24 and the Herald Sun at the Sofitel in Melbourne before 100 undecided voters, saw Wilson mock Premier Ben Carroll for refusing to say the names of his predecessors, Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan — “not Voldemort”, she told him — and declare she would not be lectured on costings by a government that had racked up $200 billion worth of debt.
Attacking that debt, and detailing her intent to get Victoria’s books in order, was one of Wilson’s strong cards in the debate, the author concedes, along with getting to the bottom of what the piece describes as institutionalised graft — some $15 billion, in the author’s words, poured into the pockets of union mates, the CFMEU in particular. The way Wilson handled the debate, the author writes, strongly suggests she has the right stuff to handle the nuts and bolts of governing.
But the wariness kicks in, the author argues, because there was another Liberal government, that of Ted Baillieu, which definitely did not fit the mould. He lasted just two years before stepping down amid dire approval ratings, replaced by Denis Napthine, who showed no more spine and fared no better. His was another two years of not much, certainly nothing that evidenced principles or political nous, the author writes — and then it was Labor’s Dan Andrews who slipped behind the premier’s desk, followed by Jacinta Allan and her successor Ben Carroll, who in the author’s view have accelerated Victoria’s descent into a sinkhole of red ink.
On its present track, the state will owe $200 billion by 2030, the piece notes — a figure that may well be a product of optimism, given that the daily interest bill is already consuming 15 per cent of the state budget.
Yet there is more to governing than filling potholes, appointing judges who don’t regard bail as a universal right, and reminding Victoria Police that all miscreants warrant equal handling, the author argues. Beyond that there is the matter of principle. If it lacks core, foundational beliefs, is a “conservative” government to be trusted? Here the Baillieu and Napthine years of go along to get along come to mind, the author writes: believe in nothing other than managerialism and that’s your destiny — nothing.
The nothingness of expedient politics came into sharp focus three weeks ago, the author writes, when Premier Carroll declared that abortions would be free of charge for any woman who wants one. The words had barely passed his lips when Wilson reacted: “There will be no changes to abortion laws under a government I lead, and I just think it is incredibly disappointing to see Ben Carroll choosing to play political football with women’s reproductive rights,” she said. But an hour or so later came a complete about-face, the author writes, as Wilson cried “Me too!” Asked at a subsequent public forum why she instantly remade her party’s already liberal abortion policies, Wilson explained that it was politics and nothing but politics — a tactical repositioning to foil “a desperate government [running] a scare campaign on women’s healthcare.”
If a long-standing policy can be jettisoned so cavalierly, the author asks, how might a Wilson government honour other promises, such as doing away with the First Nations Assembly? Wilson was a supporter of the Voice, the piece notes, which might be worth bearing in mind should she find it more difficult than expected to disassemble the Assembly. After her abortion one-eighty, faith in her resolve must surely be qualified, the author writes.
Free speech is another worry, according to the piece. “We don’t have strong enough hate-speech laws,” Wilson has said — a position the author fears would see more judgments of the kind that followed Greens senator Mehreen Faruqi’s Section 18C case against Pauline Hanson.
And then there is energy. If Victoria is to rise again, the author argues, it can only be with the benefit of much lower energy prices. Yet when asked at the debate to repudiate her party’s embrace of Net Zero, Wilson wriggled, squirmed, obfuscated and distracted with a rehearsed spiel about the need to find and exploit fresh gasfields — but not just any gas: gas would only be extracted, she made a point of noting, if obtained by traditional means, none of that nasty fracking. The author adds that Wilson’s deputy, David Southwick, has boasted that the Liberals’ push for Net Zero was even more ardent than Labor’s.
The author says it is not their intention to tell any other Victorian which party to support — what goes on in a voting booth is between a citizen and his or her pencil — but confesses a hope that, should the Coalition triumph on November 28, there will be a ginger group in the Parliament to hold the soon-to-be-premier’s feet to the fire. The pollsters say the enforcer of core principles will be One Nation. Speaking only for themself, the author writes, that wouldn’t be an unpleasant result.
Note: this is an opinion piece published by Quadrant. The views, characterisations and allegations in it — including the author’s claims about union payments and past governments — are the author’s, not established findings, and are presented here as the author’s opinion.
